No ransom will save the West.

There can be no progress while we are tied to a ridiculous system of mass entitlement and reward, not only for sloth but for criminality!

No ransom will save the West.

In following the stories out of the UK, I am saddened by the violence and senseless destruction in the nation that so many of us look to as kindred.  Many of us have a deep, almost genetic, reverence for the land of so many of our ancestors.  I certainly wish we could once again unite and rise up, standing for freedom and the greatness of the West.  Alas, not yet.
http://www.foxnews.com/world/2011/08/11/london-police-raiding-houses-over-uk-riots/?test=latestnews
It is, of course, like all such violence in places where a perfect storm of ideology brews.
Closing the trough
First, young poor people, told for decades it was the duty of the government and taxpayers to care for them, become animal-like when their feed-trough is threatened.  And, animal-like, brutal in nature, 'red in tooth and claw,' they attack the very people and places (like businesses) which provide their largesse.  Of course, they don't understand that.  Money, they reason, comes from the government.
Blinding the heart
Second, young people of other classes, middle (and doubtless properly educated upper) are swept up in the 'revolutionary' fervor.  Not so much out of need, or even real ideological conviction, but because they have been told for decades that nothing is right or wrong, and any act is reasonable if the mob allows it and provides anonymity.  It is the behavior of persons immoral and bored.  The same sort of thought that likely lies beneath the phenomenon of America's violent flash-mobs.
http://violentflashmobs.com/
There is no good, there is no evil, so do what you want.  As it says in the book of Judges:   'Each man did what was right in his own eyes.'
But why would they do this?
In many instances, in the UK and (before long in the US), apologists for these criminal acts blame the government for its austerity measures.  I suppose the government, both in the UK and in the US, is ultimately to blame.
But not for taking away the support of an entire entitlement class.  Rather, for providing it in the first place.  Riots, violence, hatred, drug abuse, cruelty, these are all the fruits of the seeds planted decades ago when well-meaning politicians decided to give and give and give to those who would ultimately refuse to contribute.  I know what I speak of.  I work in an emergency department, and the burden of false disability, addiction, child abuse, parental abdication and criminality falls heavily in America's ERs.  I am witness to it every day that I work.
But it's deeper.  As the article on the UK riots alludes, there are many trying to understand the sociological underpinnings of these behaviors.  Academics and social pundits in the US do exactly the same thing.  'Why would people riot? Is society bad?  How can we give them more?  What can we do to make life better, so that they'll be happy?'
The real, unstated question
Subtext, unstated but obvious, 'How much ransom can we offer our captors?  How many concessions can we grant our terrorists?'
The problem, dear ones, wise ones, is that the human heart is wicked.  From rich industrialists and powerful politicians all the way down to children and old ladies, with everyone in between.  Our hearts are incomplete.  Our souls are dark.  A mob, whether British, American, Chinese, African, rich, poor, educated or illiterate, is not a new thing with its own will.  It is an aggregation of many smaller, willful, dangerous hearts and minds.
The answer is higher, not lower
And no policy, no gift, no concession, will change that fundamental fact of human nature.  And only God above can redeem it from endless woe and eternal consequence.
It's an answer few desire to hear.  We live in a society that is slowly, surely, rejecting any authority higher than the fist, the sick, the knife, the gun, the stomach.  A society that bows to brutish demands; whether union protestors in Wisconsin, rioters in Philadelphia or arsonists in London.
History has not been kind to such cultures.  It may be time to look upward, to return to the Faith of our Fathers.  It may be time, after a failed experiment, to take the medicine that worked so very well, for so very long.
God help us to seek His face once more.
Edwin

Why NOT tax credits for homeschoolers?

Just a thought:  I pay property taxes as expected.  And I have since I have owned (or had a mortgage on) a home.  That money helps to support public education.

Given that many persons are changing the way they educate their children, using charter schools, parochial schools, secular private schools, online schools and home-schools, why NOT give them, give us, the amount of money we would be contributing to public education...while we are educating our own?

I understand the argument that paying for education benefits society...to the extent that it's successful and efficient.  But why shouldn't I be excused during the time my children are in primary and secondary schools?  It isn't as if my children are using the school's resources.  It's actually rather challenging for them to have access to any of it even now, when I pay taxes and home-school simultaneously.  A reality that seems a bit unjust, if you ask me.

So give parents who choose other types of alternate educational pathways a tax credit.  We aren't taking money away.  We're just moving it back home, or rather, back to the kids who will be using it.  The same way that we moved the kids out of the schools.

And just as the kids will enter the work force and public life, our tax dollars will flow right back when we're finished.

It seems a simple, fair and ethically reasonable concession to those who elect to educate their kids elsewhere...and in the process don't take up the time of public teachers, fill the chairs in public classrooms or use any of the assets of the public school in the first place.

Edwin

Welcome to Impeding Progress!

Welcome to my new blog!  You may know me from my other blog at www.edwinleap.com/blog.  That's my home.  That's the place where I write, and where I repost columns I have published in other venues. 

If you don't know me, here's a run-down.  I'm a Christian.  I'm a husband and father of four.  I'm an emergency physician.  But I'm also a writer.  For 15 years I have written a monthly column for the Greenville News, Greenville, SC.  For 11 years I have written a monthly column for Emergency Medicine News (my columns are archived here http://journals.lww.com/em-news/Pages/collectiondetails.aspx?TopicalCollectionId=6) .  My columns are often found at http://www.kevinmd.com/  or http://www.getbetterhealth.com/ , which are both excellent physician run sites.  Much of what I write concerns medicine, faith or family, with a little politics and culture thrown in. 

But I want this blog to be different.  I see blogging as a camp that is roughly divided in two.  There are blogs that are written by content producers; that's what I do.  I write all the time, and for better or worse, I publish it and hope for links, both large and small.  And there are blogs that are managed by aggregators.  That is, folks who laboriously and with passion search to and fro for information to link for the benefit of the rest of us. 

Some blogs are both.  Instapundit (http://www.instapundit.com/) comes to mind, as Glenn Reynolds both writes and links.  That's probably where I'll end up, here at 'Impeding Progress.'  I have ideas.  But I really need yours.

You see, here's the point.  There are those of us 'in the trenches.'  Physicians, businessmen, teachers, soldiers, social workers and the list goes on.  We face the public.  We pay the taxes.  We live under the heavy hand of a vast, Biblical-sized plague of rules, laws and regulations. We deal with the consequences, intended and unintended, of the things imposed on us by 'smarter people,' or 'better people.' 

We are usually too busy to lobby, to march, to travel to Washington or even to blog with any regularity.  Thus, unlike the ruling class, we are (in very real modern terms) disarmed.  No one listens to our ideas because we aren't in academia, or we aren't on any board of directors.  We aren't political consultants or business consultants. We're just doing the work. 

You'd think someone would say, 'what's going on with the masses in my field?' But it seldom happens.  What they usually say is:  'I have an idea that will make the masses better, smarter, healthier, more efficient, more compliant, safer, etc. They won't like it, but they aren't smart enough to decide for themselves.'

We, in the trenches, are struggling to make progress in this world. To help our children, to create businesses and wealth, to engage in charity, to spread our beliefs in love.  We are the true progressives.  But we are ever under the thumb of others. 

So I want your stories.  Not angry diatribes or vindictive invectives.  I want you to tell me what you do, in the real world, and how some stupid rule or regulation, some crazy tax or oversight impedes your progress, or makes the world a far, far worse place than it could be.  I know that you may be in trouble if you speak out, so if you want to remain anonymous I'm cool with that.  

Will you join in?  Let's show our 'betters' how they're impeding progress.  And give them some ideas from the trenches on how to  make things better.

Like for instance, leaving us all alone.  So that we can do something useful.
I